In the gentle parenting system, the parent rarely scolds the child for his mistakes. Instead they would explain and offer choices. However, you start wondering whether you have done it right, when you see the reaction of the child after attending a sports coaching class. The moment a coach becomes strict by raising his voice or correcting him, the child doesn't want to go back to the class. The dilemma here is two pronged. You don't want to teach your child, it's okay for someone to shout at him. And you don't want the child to walk away from every uncomfortable situation.
The view of many parents is that while gentle parenting sounds good in theory, and is certainly better than an authoritarian approach of the past, it may not be the best way to prepare children for the real world.
Gentle parenting gained momentum during the pandemic. It encouraged parents to view situations from the child's perspective, consider ther emotions and treat them with respect. It advocated using connection and communication rather than fear and shame to teach kids and promised parents calmer homes with composed and mature children.
Many parents are at the receiving end now even as the kids have grown into their teens. The parents feel the hierarchy is missing. They had looked up to their parents.They had never dared to talk back to even if they had felt their parents were unfair. But the kids are shouting at the parents with no inhibition. The children are not scared of their parents.
The problem is not with gentle parenting. It is the way it has been interpreted and misunderstood to be permissive parenting by letting children do whatever they want. Parents have pushed gentle parenting too far. They have made it almost equivalent to lack of instruction, boundaries and clarity of who is in charge. The intent behind gentle parenting was for building a home with no physical punishment, fewer instructions and deeper instructions. It is sad it has been diluted. While it is right, parents are not indulging in corporal punishment, trating the child with kid gloves is not right either.
The biggest mistake gentle parenting practitioners commit is that they don't say 'no.' They agree even if they don't want to. They furnish too many explanations to justify denying their child something. 'No' today has become an opening offer. And the day's 10 year olds are arguing every rule like lawyers. Years of explaining "no' has taught the child that a good enough argument changes the answer.
Parents definitely have to set a limit or boundary that does not shift. Parents have to say no and let the child be upset with them while they remain closeby. Children need the boundary to feel safe and thrive because their brains are still developing.They need guidance though parents do not have to rule over them.
It is seen when parents are too soft, the children are not resilient. They find it difficult to handle challenges. Parents have to be firm with children when required. They must not be allowed to disrespect the elders. They have to be the emotional anchor to the children. They must provide them freedom of choice within limits.
Please remember, 'No' is never a bad word.
Neha Bhayana writes on 'Gentle Parenting' in The Times of India 15 November 2026 -Excerpts

